Health Impact Assessment

Health Impact Assessment - Curated Guidance for Stage 1

Assess where you are in health impact assessment to determine which stage you are in and identify the key activities you need to undertake as an air  quality manager to go to the next stage. 

The guidance below is for Stage 1.
Additional guidance for Stages 2 through 5 is being developed for future iterations of AQMx.

StageCapacityData availabilityObjectivesActivitiesSustainability plan
01.
  • Basic technical training on impacts of air pollution on public health
  • No practical experience
  • No local air quality monitors, but access to global air quality datasets and other relevant data at the national level (population, mortality, morbidity)
  • Develop plan to conduct Health Impact Assessment (HIA) and gather the necessary data.
     
  • Policy mapping and analysis
  • Capacity building and stakeholder outreach
  • Data collection
  • Donor / project dependent budget
02.
  • Basic technical training on health risk assessment (HRA)
  • Some technical or analytical capacity
  • Limited practical experience
  • Access to national level air quality data and other relevant data (population, mortality, morbidity)
  • Develop a health surveillance system for air pollution
  • Conduct initial Health Risk Assessment (HRA) for air pollution
     
  • Donor / project dependent budget
  • Develop sustainability plan with continuous use of data and analysis for public health messages
03.
  • Some advanced technical or analytical capacity
  • Some practical experience
  • Air quality data and other relevant data is accessible, but not entirely robust nor comprehensive
  • Health surveillance system for air pollution starting to provide robust data
  • Emission-exposure-impact modelling
  • Limited studies on socioeconomic impacts of air pollution, qualitative variables
  • Cost-benefit / cost-effectiveness analysis
  • Some central funding
  • Routine collection of HIA-relevant health data
  • Update sustainability plan with continuous use of data and analysis for public health messages
04.
  • Advanced technical training and technical or analytical capacity
  • Extensive practical experience
  • Comprehensive and robust air quality data and other relevant data are available
  • Health surveillance system for air pollution fully deployed, acting as basis for HIA
  • Systemic epidemiologic studies on health impacts due to air pollution exposure

  • Specific HIA studies for major areas or vulnerable populations conducted using rapid assessment techniques
  • Major central funding
  • Some project dependent budget for special studies
  • Update sustainability plan with continuous use of data and analysis for public health messages
05.
  • Advanced technical training
  • Specialists in air quality management, data management, communications, economics, etc.
  • Extensive practical experience
  • Comprehensive and robust air quality data is available
  • Intersectoral and interagency agreement for data sharing
  • Health surveillance system is fully operational
  • Regular and consistent HIAs)
  • Systemic epidemiologic studies on health impacts due to air pollution exposure
  • Specific HIA studies for major areas or vulnerable populations conducted using sophisticated assessment techniques
  • Centrally funded
  • In-house research
  • Update sustainability plan with continuous use of data and analysis for public health messages

01 Commit to conducting a Health Impact Assessment

Make sure you/your department have adequate staffing, resources and authority to carry through with what is required in the Health Impact Assessment guidance (including data collection, quality assurance, and data analysis). Ensure that your management is committed to sustaining your efforts beyond your/their tenure. An overview of information on Health Impact Assessment is available in the resources below.

02 Map existing policies and identify key questions

Identify the relevant policies that need to be assessed across sectors, including household energy, waste, transport, industry, agriculture, energy and buildings, considering WHO’s One Health approach. Identify the key questions you would like to address in your Health Impact Assessment.

03 Develop capacity

Organize training/capacity building for staff in governmental institutions, academics, and experts by cooperating with institutions and specialists that can provide expertise. This basic technical training could include webinars, online courses, or in-person workshops. The goal at this stage is to develop baseline information on the health impacts of air pollution to lay the foundation to conduct a health risk assessment (HRA) in the future.

04 Conduct outreach to populations and stakeholders

Ensure participatory mechanisms to discuss the different steps and scenarios that will be developed.

05 Evaluate possible tools to conduct the air pollution health risk assessment

Modelling criteria may differ among countries because of the different levels and sources of air pollution and availability of data; however, best practices follow similar principles. In several cases there is the need to adapt and apply methodologies as dictated by available data and the information needs of policymakers and stakeholders.

06 Collect data

A key priority is to collect data input for the analysis. Data to be considered first are: 1) population data, 2) air quality data and 3) health data for mortality and morbidity following International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems (ICD) codes. To assess policies or build scenarios (for example reaching WHO Air Quality Guidelines Interim targets) it is important to have access to air quality monitoring representative of ambient conditions across the area, in particular for residential areas. For exposure characterization, it is also important to have data from potential hotspots, for example affected by traffic or industrial activities. Initial data sources can be found in the resources below.

07 Start the process to quantify the health risk from exposure to ambient air

Analyze the data with experts. Aim to provide an idea of the current burden of disease of air pollution and conduct an economic evaluation of the different scenarios evaluated. Be specific on sectors (e.g. transport, waste, etc.) contributions and impacts. Do not hide alternative solutions or potential existing conflicts. Consider also potential co-benefits related for example to reduction in noise levels or road injuries.

08 Make the data available

It is essential to make the data available to the research community and the public by establishing a public data archive that is accessible within a reasonable period and includes all the appropriate information to understand the analysis done. Future HIA and policy tracking cannot be done without publicly accessible data.

09 Develop a sustainability plan and use the data and analysis for public health messages

Developing public messages should be done targeting different audiences. Communication experts should be involved since the first step of the health impact assessment activities and should consulted on the best use of media.

10 Allow informed decisions and policy tracking

The role of policy tracking is to enable policy-makers and stakeholders to identify potential setbacks, delays, and negative impacts of policies and develop corrective measures rapidly, increasing the chance of the policy being successful.

Curated Guidance Developed by

 

WHO_Logo_Small